Techgrapher – Setup Your Online IP Centre Today
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Agriculture
      • Plant Varieties
      • Seeds
    • Biotechnology
      • Biologics
      • Pharmaceuticals
      • Food
      • Microbiology
      • Bio-medical Engineering
      • Traditional Knowledge Bio-technology
    • Electrical & Electronics
      • Electricity
      • Communication
    • Chemical
      • Agrochemicals
      • Pharmaceuticals
      • Polymers
      • Metallurgy
      • Traditional Knowledge Chemical
      • Medical Science
      • Veterinary Science
      • Organic Chemistry
      • Inorganic Chemistry
      • Treatment of Water
      • Petroleum
      • Bio-chemistry
      • Mining
      • Combinatorial Technology
      • Textiles
      • Paper
      • Nanotechnology
    • Mechanical
      • General Engineering
      • Physics
      • Agriculture Engineering
      • Traditional Knowledge Mechanical
      • Automotive
      • Engines
      • Lighting
      • Heating
      • Weapons
      • Instruments
      • Pumps
      • Blasting
      • Microstructural Technology
    • Civil
      • Hydraulic Engineering
      • Building
      • Earth Drilling
      • Infrastructure
    • Computer Science
      • Artificial Intelligence
      • Big Data
      • Machine Learning
      • Cryptocurrency
      • Blockchain
    • Physics
      • Instruments
      • Nucleonics
    • IP Centre
  • Pricing
  • ConsultHot
  • Login
  • My Account
    • Edit Profile
  •  Log In Sign Up
Techgrapher – Setup Your Online IP Centre Today
  • Home
  • Articles
    • Agriculture
      • Plant Varieties
      • Seeds
    • Biotechnology
      • Biologics
      • Pharmaceuticals
      • Food
      • Microbiology
      • Bio-medical Engineering
      • Traditional Knowledge Bio-technology
    • Electrical & Electronics
      • Electricity
      • Communication
    • Chemical
      • Agrochemicals
      • Pharmaceuticals
      • Polymers
      • Metallurgy
      • Traditional Knowledge Chemical
      • Medical Science
      • Veterinary Science
      • Organic Chemistry
      • Inorganic Chemistry
      • Treatment of Water
      • Petroleum
      • Bio-chemistry
      • Mining
      • Combinatorial Technology
      • Textiles
      • Paper
      • Nanotechnology
    • Mechanical
      • General Engineering
      • Physics
      • Agriculture Engineering
      • Traditional Knowledge Mechanical
      • Automotive
      • Engines
      • Lighting
      • Heating
      • Weapons
      • Instruments
      • Pumps
      • Blasting
      • Microstructural Technology
    • Civil
      • Hydraulic Engineering
      • Building
      • Earth Drilling
      • Infrastructure
    • Computer Science
      • Artificial Intelligence
      • Big Data
      • Machine Learning
      • Cryptocurrency
      • Blockchain
    • Physics
      • Instruments
      • Nucleonics
    • IP Centre
  • Pricing
  • ConsultHot
  • Login
  • My Account
    • Edit Profile
  •  Log In Sign Up
0
  • Chemical
  • Pharmaceuticals

Numerical Ranges in Pharmaceutical Patents

  • April 20, 2019
  • No comments
  • 441 views
  • 2 minute read
  • Dr. Venkata Subramanian Raman
Total
0
Shares
0
0
0
0
0
Total
0
Shares
Share 0
Share 0
Tweet 0
Share 0
Share 0
Book a Call
The operational limits of the inventions are confined to the limits set by the numerical ranges. The numerical range signifies the limit to which the invention is covered. These include ranges associated with physical parameters such as temperature, pressure, and also chemical parameters including chemical compositions. How to claim numerical ranges? Are there restrictions in claiming numerical range beyond the restrictions imposed by the prior art? The US patent law mandates that the numerical range must comply with the written description requirement. In an interesting case, the US court withheld an application based on the written description requirement for defining a specific example of 36% when the complete specification disclosed a range between 25% to 60% .1 However, when the claim was amended to include a range, closer to the lower limit of a specific example “between 35% and 60%”, the court allowed the patent, which was in compliance with the written description requirement after the amendment. An ideal example to highlight this would be an Indian application, 673/DELNP/2004, on the composition of an excipient in a formulation, which disclosed the ranges for the degree of methyl and hydroxy substitution in hydroxypropyl methyl celluloses, closer to either the lower (15% to about 35%) or the upper limit (2% to about 15%) (shown below) and adhered to the norms set by the written description requirement.  
Numerical ranges for degree of substitution
Numerical ranges for degree of substitution
If the narrow ranges are covered by reference to a specific example, how to cover broader ranges and still comply with the written description requirement? In such cases, the complete specification must carry different sets of numerical range along with specific examples to map and cover portions for intermittent ranges. This can be best understood with 82/DELNP/2010, application on the composition of Azeotropic mixture of HFO-1234 /propane, which maps broader range from 0 to 100 and still captures either a lower or upper limit for this broader range.
Numerical range covering broader ranges
Numerical range covering broader ranges
Another interesting case law on numerical ranges is Eiselstein V. Frank (1995), wherein the use of “about” in describing the alloy with a Nickel content of “45% to 50%” failed to cover an alloy within a range from “50% to about 60%”.2 The use of “about” sets the limit of approximation and does not stretch beyond the limit proposed. In the above example, 82/DELNP/2010, “zero to about 50%”, “zero to about 40%” , “5 wt% to about 45 wt%”, sets the numerical range limit to the number defined by “about”. And use of “preferably” or “preferred” is common in disclosing the numerical ranges, which either explains the sweet spot of the invention or suggested range to carry out the invention. The following example from the Indian application, 262/DELNP/2005, discloses a composition of an active ingredient in a preferred range. But care must be exercised in practice, it does not exclude the broader range covered.
Numerical Ranges 262DELNP2005
Numerical Ranges 262DELNP2005
In essence, the numerical ranges has to be used in the claim with clear distinction from the prior art and adhere to the standards set by the written description requirement. And most importantly, the ranges claimed must match the ranges covered in the embodiment.  
BOOK A CALL | FREE (Limited Time)

REFERENCES:

  1. In re Wertheim, 541 F.2d 257, 191 USPQ 90 (CCPA 1976)
  2. https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-federal-circuit/1217871.html
Total
0
Shares
Share 0
Share 0
Tweet 0
Share 0
Share 0
Dr. Venkata Subramanian Raman

Dr. Venkat specializes in Chemical, Pharmaceutical and Life Sciences, who received his Master's degree in Chemistry from IIT Madras and earned Ph.D in Chemistry from Tufts University. He is a registered Patent Agent (IN/PA 3924). Prior to joining Techgrapher, he worked as a Patent Analyst, analyzed Patent Applications for USPTO, at CPA Global (Michigan) and learned commercializing research products during his tenure at Technology Transfer Office in Tufts University, Boston.

Related Topics
  • Eiselstein V. Frank (1995)
  • Numerical Ranges
  • Written Description Requirement
You May Also Like
Impurity matters
View Post
  • Bio-chemistry
  • Chemical

Impurity Matters

  • February 4, 2020
  • Dr. Venkata Subramanian Raman
How Indian Patent Office Rejected Patent Applications on Artificial Sweeteners
View Post
  • Chemical
  • Pharmaceuticals

How the Indian Patent Office Rejected Applications on Artificial Sweeteners

  • June 9, 2019
  • Dr. Archana Thakur
View Post
  • Chemical
  • Pharmaceuticals

Patent Study on Stevia Sweeteners: An Indian Perspective

  • May 10, 2019
  • Dr. Archana Thakur
Negative Limitations in Pharmaceutical Patents
View Post
  • Chemical
  • Pharmaceuticals

Introducing Negative Limitations in Pharmaceutical Patents

  • April 21, 2019
  • Dr. Venkata Subramanian Raman
Understanding Pharmaceutical Patents
View Post
  • Chemical
  • Pharmaceuticals

Understanding Pharmaceutical Patents

  • April 20, 2019
  • Dr. Venkata Subramanian Raman

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Techgrapher – Setup Your Online IP Centre Today
  • About
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  •  Log In Sign Up
Do Intellectual Property Right

Input your search keywords and press Enter.